• News

PARALYSIS BY ANALYSIS: PROFITABILITY PAINTS A PICTURE

The last three years of horror have definitely delivered the thrills, the chills, but most of all the dollar bills. For studio executives, tales of haunted houses, creepy clowns, and at least a psycho slasher or two have demonstrated returns that even the Dow has yet to top. But wait! What about the ratings system? Does that play a role? What strategic considerations are made when pouring considerable sums of capital into these hit makers?

Data gathered from 2015-2017 exhibits some of the most impressive box-office performers, arranged by rating and gross returns:

Given the relatively recent rise in the volume of PG-13 rated horror films produced, one could have assumed that studios are simply trying to pack the picture house with as many popcorn-munching, soda-sipping seat warmers as possible. After all, if adolescents don’t need to be accompanied by an adult to gain entry to a film, they can descend en masse opening weekend and propel the latest installment of a torture happy maniac to number one! However, facts and figures don’t lie.

True to its form, the genre-dominating R-rated horror film still manages to outperform its more watered down cousin in sheer gross profits alone. In fact, if this data sample is any indication, attempting to broaden the audience base by siphoning the tourniquet may actually be doing more harm than good. Fans know what they want, and box-office receipts like these shout the message to the rooftops of theaters nationwide.

Granted, the PG-13 rated films clustered at the bottom of this list still boast returns as great as four times their budgets, the correlation is clear. Blumhouse’s HAPPY DEATH DAY aside (personal favorite/shameless plug), an R rating really restricts one thing and one thing only: the odds of studio bankruptcy.

Read More

Get The Grim Reader.
Rue Morgue's free newsletter.
Editor's notes.
Cultural insight.
Curated horror across film, books, music, and art.
First looks.
Select previews.
No algorithms.
Join Free

Advertisement

In Print Since 1997

Issue 231

Rue Morgue #231 Jul/Aug 2026

Plus

Inside Rue Morgue #231 – Summer Slasher Issue FEATURES Filmmaker Jane Schoenbrun’s TEENAGE SEX AND DEATH AT CAMP MIASMA guts the slasher formula from the inside out, turning it into a romance about the horror of becoming who you were always meant to be. Plus! GILLIAN ANDERSON and HANNAH EINBINDER unpack Schoenbrun’s radical dismemberment of…

Issue 230

Rue Morgue #230 May/Jun 2026 – RARE

Plus

Inside Rue Morgue #230 FEATURES Filmmaker Curry Barker transforms a simple wish into a spiralling nightmare of love, possession, and bloodshed in his breakout feature OBSESSION. Plus: The story of Barker’s found-footage shocker MILK & SERIAL, which turned a micro-budget experiment into a viral horror breakout. Hollywood made it a monster. History tells a different…

Issue 229

Rue Morgue #229 Mar/Apr 2026

Plus

Inside Rue Morgue #229! FEATURES A nerve-shredding found-footage thriller built around sound, UNDERTONE signals the arrival of a terrifying new voice in Canada’s booming independent horror scene. Plus! Meet the new breed of independent Canadian horror filmmakers behind DREAM EATER, SWEETNESS, HANGASHORE, THE LAND OF NOD and THE CURSE OF GHOST ISLAND. Part post-punk, part…

Issue 228

Rue Morgue #228 Jan/Feb 2026

Plus

Inside Rue Morgue #228! FEATURES He fascinated audiences in 2001 with the French period martial arts horror film BROTHERHOOD OF THE WOLF. Then he followed it up in 2006 by bringing the eerie world of SILENT HILL to cinematic life. Now, visionary director CHRISTOPHE GANS unleashes his latest nightmare with RETURN TO SILENT HILL. Plus!…