A spooky staple amongst Toronto’s cinephiles and cine-fans, the annual TORONTO AFTER DARK FILM FESTIVAL ran this year from October 14th–18th at the Scotiabank Theatre with late night screenings at Cinecycle and a social hub at Escape Manor. The festival opened with two highly anticipated titles both experiencing their Canadian premieres: Brian Duffield’s Whalefall, starring James Brolin, Austin Adams and Elisabeth Shue, and Ben Sottak’s Hallowarrior, starring Milly Shapiro, Shannyn Sossamon and Ajani Russell.
Duffield was unable to attend. Instead, he left a prerecorded message full of gratitude for everyone who came to see the film. Whalefall, based on the novel by Daniel Krause of the same name, was a nautical nightmare, almost biblical in its depiction of the depths and its creatures. After his father (James Brolin) dies at sea, Jay (Austin Adams) goes diving to retrieve his body. While underwater, he becomes tangled between a sperm whale and his lunch and is swallowed whole. Jay dives back into memories with his father, grasping at any knowledge he was taught about the sea to survive.

Austin Adams seems to have a knack for adding cheekiness to characters who are experiencing the worst days of their lives, often finding themselves in the wrong place at the wrong time. Whalefall was a surprisingly emotional, visually Lovecraftian tale about a tumultuous relationship between a man and his son, the desire to leave home and the hard-fought peace required to come back.
The second screening, Hallowarrior, was an autumnal, post-apocalyptic, home-invasion horror. 16-year-old Pumpkin (Milly Shapiro) preps for her favorite time of the year: Halloween. Living in a post-apocalyptic world, Pumpkin craves companionship. However, the “companions” that arrive reveal themselves to be, in Pumpkin’s words, “not good people”. Forget razors and poison in your Halloween candy. The moral of this story is don’t open your door to strangers.

Writer/Director Sottak and star Shapiro were present for a Q&A after the film. Sottak voiced that his intention was to create an “autumnal horror movie”. He harkened back to examples such as Trick or Treat and Halloween. And he absolutely hit the nail on the head. Despite containing lots of blood, rot and fright, Hallowarrior did have a cozy, vintage Halloween feel. Hallowarrior was also the first film of the festival to include ScareScore. A sponsor of this year’s festival, ScareScore is an app that tracks your body’s physical reactions while you watch horror movies.
Each screening opened with a beautifully animated short. Whalefall was proceeded by The Old Gods by Noah Van Buhran, in which a creature wreaks havoc Godzilla-style. Hallowarrior was proceeded by Run From It, created by Seneca students Kory Kongsommart and Jun Jeung. The film is a very sweet animated short where two friends explore a spooky house.
Whalefall won best cinematography, best sound design and best special effects. Hallowarrior took home the 2026 ScareScore trophy and won best costume design while also earning the audience vote for “The Film You Most Want to See a Sequel To.”
Whalefall is currently in theaters. Hallowarrior is available to stream on Shudder.



















