• Sunday, Bloody, Funday

Fall in love with these handmade horror plushies from Buttercruds

Who hasn’t ever wanted a plushie version of the horror genre’s most iconic characters? Turns out Mikey Sarago (better known as Buttercruds) of New York has turned the idea into a reality. Sarago’s line of handmade horror dolls and plushies run the gammut of who’s who in horror movie fandom, from Friday the 13th, Halloween, and Sleepaway Camp (a plushie that has to be seen to be believed), along with others.

Sarago’s love of horror began with life-altering trips to the video store, which yielded multiple viewings of The Exorcist and a desire to create his own art niche. His decade long hobby for doll making happened by accident; after finding a rip in one of his favourite t-shirts, Sarago decided to use the fabric to create a spooky little doll. His passion for the horror genre was the match that sparked a business in handmade dolls, hence Buttercruds.etsy.com was founded.

 


All the dolls at Buttercruds are made-to-order and take about two to four weeks to complete and ship. Size options for the dolls are available, with full-sized dolls measuring 15 inches tall, while the ‘baby’ varieties stand approximately 9 inches. All dolls consist of felt, fleece, with embroiled faces and yarn for hair (if the characters require hair, that is). Prices range from $30-$65 USD (plus shipping).

So do yourself some dolls at the Buttercruds store, or on Mikey Sarago’s personal Instagram account!

Buttercruds Etsy
Mikey Sarago Instagram

Read More

Get The Grim Reader.
Rue Morgue's free newsletter.
Editor's notes.
Cultural insight.
Curated horror across film, books, music, and art.
First looks.
Select previews.
No algorithms.
Join Free

Advertisement

In Print Since 1997

Issue 231

Rue Morgue #231 Jul/Aug 2026

Plus

Inside Rue Morgue #231 – Summer Slasher Issue FEATURES Filmmaker Jane Schoenbrun’s TEENAGE SEX AND DEATH AT CAMP MIASMA guts the slasher formula from the inside out, turning it into a romance about the horror of becoming who you were always meant to be. Plus! GILLIAN ANDERSON and HANNAH EINBINDER unpack Schoenbrun’s radical dismemberment of…

Issue 230

Rue Morgue #230 May/Jun 2026 – RARE

Plus

Inside Rue Morgue #230 FEATURES Filmmaker Curry Barker transforms a simple wish into a spiralling nightmare of love, possession, and bloodshed in his breakout feature OBSESSION. Plus: The story of Barker’s found-footage shocker MILK & SERIAL, which turned a micro-budget experiment into a viral horror breakout. Hollywood made it a monster. History tells a different…

Issue 229

Rue Morgue #229 Mar/Apr 2026

Plus

Inside Rue Morgue #229! FEATURES A nerve-shredding found-footage thriller built around sound, UNDERTONE signals the arrival of a terrifying new voice in Canada’s booming independent horror scene. Plus! Meet the new breed of independent Canadian horror filmmakers behind DREAM EATER, SWEETNESS, HANGASHORE, THE LAND OF NOD and THE CURSE OF GHOST ISLAND. Part post-punk, part…

Issue 228

Rue Morgue #228 Jan/Feb 2026

Plus

Inside Rue Morgue #228! FEATURES He fascinated audiences in 2001 with the French period martial arts horror film BROTHERHOOD OF THE WOLF. Then he followed it up in 2006 by bringing the eerie world of SILENT HILL to cinematic life. Now, visionary director CHRISTOPHE GANS unleashes his latest nightmare with RETURN TO SILENT HILL. Plus!…